Practice · 2023–now · AI Present

AI will rewrite the codebase

Big-bang rewrite, now with a chatbot — then with agents. Same failure mode; prettier slides.

Why AI will rewrite the codebase became a costly fad

AI rewrites fail for the same reasons manual ones do: unknown edge cases, missing tests, and political ownership of legacy modules. LLMs accelerate typing, not accountability. Strangler migrations still win; autopilot and agentic-migration slides still lie.

Cost of the fad

What AI will rewrite the codebase cost

Exec decks promised autonomous migrations "by next quarter," then rebranded as "agentic modernization." Teams that skipped tests, ownership, and incremental strangler patterns bought expensive demos and fragile diffs.

Case studies

Patterns

2022–now

AI Present

Part of the AI Present era (2022–now).

Read the AI Present era →

Compare with

Related

Practice · 1995–now

Big-bang rewrite

Costly fad

Replace the working system instead of strangling it. A perennial money pit with new branding each decade.

$ "We'll freeze features and rewrite in the hot language." Multi-year projects shipped late, incomplete, or not at all — while competitors iterated on the ugly system that made money.

Framework · 2023–now

LLM app frameworks

Mutated

LangChain-class glue mutated into MCP clients and thin wrappers around vendor APIs. The durable pieces are still boring: evals, retrieval, and product UX.

Practice · 2021–now

AI pair programming

Stuck

Coding agents that edit the repo — now table stakes. Generation outran review capacity; ownership is the bottleneck.

Practice · 2024–now

Vibe coding

Costly fad

Accept AI output on feel, skip the diff, hope tests exist. Fast demos; CVEs and nobody owns the middleware.

$ Ship-to-prod without reading the diff became a flex until incidents revealed nobody knew which prompt wrote the auth middleware. Review debt arrived in one weekend demo.

Framework · 2023–now

Multi-agent orchestration hype

Mutated

LangGraph, CrewAI, AutoGPT cosplay — then vendor harnesses shipped the same loop as an API. Open-source swarms faded; leased orchestration stuck.

$ Autonomous agent swarms burned API budgets on coordination loops that a single prompt and a cron job would have handled. Debugging "which agent lied" became the new on-call sport.

Platform · 2025–now

Vendor agent APIs

Mutated

The Codex/Claude loop as a product SKU — durable sessions, compaction, subagents, and a sandbox you do not own.

$ Teams replaced a weekend of LangGraph glue with a managed session API, then discovered residency, recovery, and kill switches all live on the vendor side of the harness.

© 2026 Fadstack · Shane Code · Privacy

Opinionated history · not a ranking

Site updates

Occasional Fadstack notes. Confirm by email — this list stays off the book and advisory lists.

I use the address for Fadstack updates only. Privacy.